Abstract

This paper aims to demonstrate the bleak changes in peoples’ lives. These changes occurred because of the rise of influencer culture, these celebrity influencers affected every aspect of peoples’ lives. I’m arguing to create awareness to the issue, asking from people to be mindful of the goals of these influences and de code what their messages saying. The paper is backed up by scholarly research and supported by evidence from my own personal experiences and major stories seen/ heard around the world that demonstrates the real power of an influencer and demonstrates the problem we are facing as a society.

The digital age brought along new norms and previously unknown forms of communication. Norms and forms of communication that gave so-called “ social Influencers” great power to shape our lives and identities. For example when certain celebrities like Kim Kardashian or Kanye West release or endorse a new product followers hurry up and stand in lines for hours to be one of the first to purchase it. Why do they do that? The obvious answer in the digital era, so they may log into their Instagram account and post their newly purchased product giving them pride and joy in being associated with such a celebrity. Actually, and if one looks deeper one can observe the rise of a phenomenal relationship in which social Influencers gain further and further power to not only affect our consumer behaviour but also our social life patterns, our major decisions, and even our values, ethics and morals.

Nowadays individuals and families continuously interact with each other on the web posting non-stop daily activities that would eventually become their social memories. A baby’s first ultrasound is posted online by the parents to share this moment with their family and friends. Days or weeks later and as soon as the gender of that baby is known everyone in the community is altered through a social media platform. And from that moment a new digital identity starts to be recorded for that specific baby and algorithms are used to add all available data about the new individual. He/she becomes a single focus point in the digital world. To mark that single focus point most people would add captions attempting to find an association with the celebrities they follow. And the baby, who is not born yet, becomes a social being affiliated with celebrities we already follow. Thus, feeding The powers of the enormous information and reconnaissance free enterprise. And un- knowingly supporting the huge information inclination, advanced by Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg who insists on the morals of an incorporated character, a solitary variant of selfhood kept up with across diverse settings and human connections (Kim, 2018).

Furthermore, we can see this incorporated character in the study today social relationships in general which can be divided into two categories: real and virtual, with the second overtaking the first one quickly. Actually, most young people today consider virtual relationships with built-in communities focused around celebrities more interesting and engaging. For example, many young people find Cristiano Ronaldo’s fan page to be the place where true friendships are born as part of the fan’s community.

Going back now to the process of decision making, like the decision of post our babies first ultrasound. One might ask why? Why do we need to inform everyone about such a matter? The probable answer is that may be because just to share the moment yet the more probable answer is that more and more people are copycat influencers to make them feel good about most of their day-to-day decisions. If it is trendy (led by influencers) to post a baby’s first ultrasound then we should not miss on that. Actually, most young people want to eat and travel to the same places influencers recommend to them. Furthermore, lots of young people dream to purchase cars celebrities drive and live in homes that look like their homes. Stranger than that some go even as far as wanting to copy their idols mood, diet, and even their alcohol and nonalcoholic beverages. One can recall here Cristiano Ronaldo gesturing that he doesn’t drink Coca-Cola. A mere gesture that cost that company more than a billion dollars in the following week.

The brain science literature informs people that superstar guidance conditions individuals to respond emphatically toward it. Individuals are likewise disposed to follow big names assuming the guidance matches their self-originations or on the other hand on the off chance that the superstar looks like it and fits the objective of the exhortation given. Going back to the example above, Cristiano Ronaldo has an extremely low body fat percentage and a great amount of muscle so when he gestures against drinking Coca-Cola, the advice resonates easily in the brain of the viewer. Social science makes sense of how celebrities’ recommendations spread through social media, how their impact is a sign of individuals’ craving to obtain big names, and social capital, and how they influence the manner in which individuals gain and decipher wellbeing information (Hoffman, 2015).

What really gives influencers such power? Influencers first gain the trust and fellowship of their devotees by planning body-shape centre visual substance and designated correspondence methods. They recognise and characterise diet, exercise, and supplements as variables to be controlled for body flawlessness. By consuming dietary enhancements and wearing tight-fitting marked active apparel, celebrities promise an improved approach to advancing one’s appearance as the key to bliss. Direct and clandestine advertising of industry-explicit items constitutes the communicative focus (Pilgrim, 2019).

Going deeper, researchers believe that it all boils down to how influencers used individual intimacy to cover the business exchanges of their web-based mingling? How they commandeered customised hashtags belonging to a place with noticeable contenders to wrestle for attention? Influencers are considered as assessment pioneers for youthful web clients,” who speak with adherents through their successful advanced strategies applied across an assortment of possibly incorporated social media platforms and sit at the convergence of relatability politics, attention gaming economies, and self-branding culture (Abidin, 2021). The fast-growing influencer industries around the world have requested different clear-cut limits for deciding the class of an Influencer, to be specific, country, culture, stage, and sort. In nations like Denmark with a population of 5.8 million and Sweden with a population of 10.2 million, a “mega Influencer” is unified with north of 1,000,000 adherents, while amateurs and hopefuls with less than 1000 devotees can likewise be thought of as “nano-influencers”. Accordingly, an Influencer’s class decides their essential role in data biology, whether this be filling in as intensifiers of data, assessment pioneers, or convincing converters (Abidin, 2021).

Another more serious area of influence celebrities and social influencers have is on personal values, morals, and even more on political and social points of view. The complex network was previously believed to be extremely difficult to direct or change. Scary enough, Influencers today can do what no philosophical or ethical preachers could do. We all remember the time when all that ex-president Trump needed is the endorsement of an influencer with a large enough following like Dwayne Johnson to be re-elected. Views are tied to celebrities and their beliefs. It’s a relief that he did not endorse Trump.

An interesting example of the influence of celebrities influence on identity and ethics is the intriguing debate around celebrity Caitlyn Jenner formerly known as Bruce Jenner an Olympic gold medalist adored in the United States. Actually, it all started when he/she announced his transformation into a female and the galvanisation of the community #Girlslikeus which had a powerful spokesperson in Hollywood. Caitlyn appeared on all the famous talk shows like Ellen and Oprah promoting his transformation and advocating for the transgender community. Comedian Dave Chappell claimed that African Americans are jealous of the trans community, jealous of how fast the trans community is moving forward and earning their rights in the United States. After his show, Dave Chappell was Attacked on every social media platform by various movements. Showing that the trans community has influenced many peoples’ values that they believed such a joke was out of line and Dave Chappell should be legally punished for crossing that line.

It is worth explaining here how the hashtags were used in the example of Caitlyn Jenner as a weapon that shaped the values of many people. Yes, the movement #Girlslikeus which started by a transgender female named Mock, at the time when she first created the hashtag it had less than 3000 followers but quickly grew as she was relentlessly active on platforms like Twitter. More people started joining the movement turning it into a community with a voice that must be heard. Straight females joined this community and Mock became a celebrity in the United States for creating this community and giving them a voice. The hashtag #Girlslikeus became a community that’s trending on a massive network across the globe. They targeted transgender black females to join them because of the power of ethnic background and the fact that African Americans have suffered in the United States with all kinds of racial abuse since the united states were founded as a country, they joined the movement because it was masked as an equal rights movement. Equal rights are something that African Americans and women have been fighting for. When they brought in different forces joining hands they gave themselves political leverage and had a say on new laws regarding the transgender community, the affected new laws and made it illegal to use some famous definitions of the word transgender like the word queer (Jackson, 2018).

Another strong influencer in the digital age is algorithms. It presents views with the celebrity posts, ads, news, and hashtags that best suit their taste relying on previous searches on google and other search engines. Text messages are shared with their contacts and the apps that they download to keep feeding you the kind of information that would interest them as an individual. For example, I traveled to Egypt last month, ever since I booked my flight I kept receiving ads about car rentals in Cairo on Instagram and store promotions selling Egyptian souvenirs and all kinds of experiences being sold in Cairo and around Egypt. On my Instagram explore page I kept seeing posts of local celebrities and the gorgeous experiences they’re living in Cairo and around Egypt. Since I departed from Cairo to Cyprus I kept seeing ads about cheap flights to Cairo some days the prices were very tempting to the point where I considered altering my current path in life to go back and visit Cairo simply because of what the ad had to offer (Kim, 2018).

The ramifications for the planning of space by Internet web search engines, for example, Google are unclear, however, they propose the disintegration of the qualification between the private and public society. For example, it has been assessed that close to half of all Internet clients are Americans. The spectre of the digital divide has turned into a profoundly effective issue in current discussions on data and correspondence advancements (Delanty, 2018). A famous misinterpretation of Influencers’ utilisation of virtual entertainment is that they generally go for the maximum attention and maximum publicity. However, among algorithmic and simple work, Influencers balance hyper-visibility and under visibility to stay away from over-openness in certain areas and divert crowd interest to other people. people who can be influenced by these celebrities (Abidin, 2021).

signing up for a social media site, or downloading and utilising a virtual entertainment application, is arranged legitimately as a relationship between an organisation and a singular client. Also, challenges as far as the manner in which digital information is made, gathered, totalled, and marketed are most frequently tended to by proposing individual clients ought to be enabled with more office, better security, and more strong advanced skill levels (Leaver, 2015). A large portion of people can independently answer the inquiry concerning who we are in particular settings, while the possibility of being expected to settle on an ultimate choice about our character is conceded: not many of us have been compelled to address whether or not we have multiple personalities for different settings of our lives. However, that is evolving. One of the focal impacts of contemporary enormous information innovation is that it applies strain to respond to the enduring moral inquiry regarding individual personality and multiplicity (Kim, 2018). One of the focal impacts of contemporary enormous information innovation is that it applies strain to respond to the perpetual moral inquiry concerning individual identity and assortment. Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg catches the truth while stating: “you have one identity. The days of you having a different image for your co-workers, and for the other people you know, are coming to an end. Having two identities for yourself is an example of a lack of integrity” (Kim, 2018).

In conclusion, social influencers and celebrities are suddenly doing what great people once wished to do but unfortunately, not always in a positive way. The modern communication tools open our minds and homes for them and allowed them to redefine many aspects of our humanity ranging from simply influencing our consumer behaviour and going as far as defining our ethics and social self-image. A very dangerous turn that is going beyond the personal to the historical, which calls for a serious pause and deep social debate. More data is required to understand the depth of the issue, suggested area of further study is the changes in percentage of a population in a controlled environment before exposure to influencers and after exposure.

Reference List:

Li, M. (2018). Intermedia attribute agenda setting in the context of issue-focused media events: Caitlyn Jenner and transgender reporting. Journalism practice, 12(1), 56-75.

Pilgrim, K., & Bohnet-Joschko, S. (2019). Selling health and happiness how influencers communicate on Instagram about dieting and exercise: Mixed methods research. BMC public health, 19(1), 1-9.

Hoffman, S. J., & Tan, C. (2015). Biological, psychological and social processes that explain celebrities’ influence on patients’ health-related behaviors. Archives of Public Health, 73(1), 1-11.

Jackson, S. J., Bailey, M., & Welles, B. F. (2020). # HashtagActivism: Networks of race and gender justice. Mit Press.

Abidin, C. (2021). From “networked publics” to “refracted publics”: A companion framework for researching “below the radar” studies. Social Media+ Society, 7(1), 2056305120984458

Kim, J., & Hastak, M. (2018). Social network analysis: Characteristics of online social networks after a disaster. International journal of information management, 38(1), 86-96.

Leaver, T. (2015). Researching the ends of identity: Birth and death on social media. Social Media+ Society, 1(1), 2056305115578877.

Jackson, S. J., Bailey, M., & Foucault Welles, B. (2018). # GirlsLikeUs: Trans advocacy and community building online. New Media & Society, 20(5), 1868-1888.

Delanty, G. (2018). Community: 3rd edition (3rd ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315158259

16 thoughts on “influencers creating bleak identities

  1. Antony Schillaci says:

    This is a really interesting paper. The question I asked myself when reading it was when did the celebrity influencer become the influencer celebrity? Whilst the celebrity was the original influencer, now I see many influencers create a profile for themselves that makes them a “celebrity” and their identity becomes a total construct of social media, with no prior history for reference – and with the single goal of manipulating a consumer. I totally agree that with you that there is a need for a “serious pause and deep social debate”. I have written a paper which looks at the fashion industry, its use of influencers and the impact on the mental health of young women. It would be great to hear your thoughts on whether this is almost an adjunct to your paper. Here is a link for your reference:

    https://networkconference.netstudies.org/2022/csm/113/youd-be-correct-if-you-thought-the-fashion-industrys-use-of-instagram-has-had-a-negative-impact-on-young-women/

    • Adel Shalan says:

      Thanks Antony. I agree, today almost anyone with the right skill set can become a influencer. They thrive in all industries from health to fashion brainwashing the consumer as they go on pursuing their goals and dreams. Thanks for sharing the link to your paper, I will give it a read then we can discuss further.

  2. Brendan Cohen says:

    I enjoyed reading your paper, Adel. Made me weigh up what I see as the positive influencers, and those more bent on self-promotion or just wreaking identity chaos amongst the vulnerable. (eg. Kardashians) Ricky Gervais is a wonderful example of what I consider a positive influencer. Huge following, enormous star power, which I think he wields to try to make people think, and to tear down some of the more hypocritical ‘stars’ and celebrities out there. Our networked world is just a smidgen better thanks to Ricky Gervais. Worth reading Andrea Perry’s paper in this section.

  3. Anne-Marie Tatyanna Rachel Kimberley Penny says:

    Hi Adel,
    After reading your article , I acknowledge that influencers play a tremendous role in people’s decisions but not all young people who dream to possess the cars which celebrities drive, succeed in making their dreams come true, so, don’t you think that in such cases, most influencers fail in their role ?
    It is amazing how because of a mere gesture from a celebrity, a company can lose billions of dollars.

    I have written a paper also, here is the link to access it https://networkconference.netstudies.org/2022/csm/999/the-natural-hair…ro-textured-hair/
    It is about Africans’ textured hair issues and I would much appreciate your comments.

    Your article is an interesting one and I found pleasure in reading it.
    Tatyanna.

    • Adel Shalan says:

      Hello Anne-Marie. I agree not everyone would be able to make such purchases but dreaming and feeling the need to succeed to purchase a car similar to one of an Influencer is forming an identity. It would make that individual feel less of themselves because they cannot afford it. I will definitely give your paper a read. Thanks for your comment.

  4. Tracy Kim says:

    Hi Adel,
    Great article, it is worrisome to think about how influential some of these influencers can be.
    I liked your point about Mark Zuckerberg and him considering multiple identities as a lack of integrity. This leaves no room for consideration that most people only show one side of their identity online, so even if you have one true identity online, how are we sure that we are seeing the whole person? I have a similar explanation of this in my paper,
    https://networkconference.netstudies.org/2022/ioa/184/negotiation-of-privacy-and-social-media-to-explore-lgbtqia-identity-and-advocate-for-their-communities/
    but on a flip side, of what happens when people are still trying to figure out who they are, and how can they do that safely if they are persecuted for changing or not being deemed a ‘normal’ person.
    I also talked about #GirlsLikeUs, but how many users are finding support and community while expressing their identities and common struggles, normalising trans people to the wider population.
    Thanks, Tracy.

    • Adel Shalan says:

      Hello Tracy. Thanks for your comment and your great summary of all the important points in my paper. I just finished reading your paper and I enjoyed how you argued a similar argument to mine with different claims but eventually reaching the same conclusion about the loss of identity in the social media age.

  5. Rachel Sherry says:

    Hi Adel,
    Thankyou for a great paper! Celebrity endorsement/ manipulation is something I have been aware for a while now, but I am still guilty of giving in to buying a product because a celebrity is wearing it. I was actually reading an article on a Beauty Youtuber named Michelle Phan, who has a massive following and is known for her makeup tutorials. Recently, she has changed her content and has begun promoting ideas that could be harmful to her followers, such as claiming that using essential oils will prevent you from getting covid. It is scary how impressionable the followers of influencers are, so when their content is off base or controversial it can have a negative impact on their community. My question for you is, do you think some followers may be too far gone? Meaning they are following an influencers every word and changing their lifestyle as a result of viewing their content. Do you think it is too late to reverse the damage some individuals have already endured as a result of brainwashing by social media manipulation at the hands of influencers and celebrities? I am talking in the extremes here, say if an influencer was anti-vax and constantly producing content based on conspiracy theories/ biased information. Would love to hear your thoughts!

    • Adel Shalan says:

      Hi Rachel.
      I enjoyed the example you mentioned about Michelle Phan. Sadly there’s a lot of these cases today all over social media. To answer your question I had to do some research, I found out that all it takes for someone to start re-shaping their identity is a realization and awareness of what’s happening but to truly assess if that individual is too far gone. Further studies are required to answer that question.

  6. Riya Srivastava says:

    Hi Adel,

    I enjoyed reading your paper. Writing about influencer culture in my paper and reading about it from multiple perspectives in various papers has been a refreshing and interesting feeling. I liked all the examples that very well supported your arguments. Influencers do have a strong say in the political, cultural, and almost every aspect of life these days. The life of a common Instagram user, for example, is greatly governed by the social media influencers selling an ideal body, lifestyle, fashion sense, and food habits. Whilst following food bloggers or travel bloggers can be an interesting thing to do as they help people like me, to explore new and great places to eat and travel, sometimes influencer marketing goes the wrong way too.. in selling a highly imaginative and unattainable lifestyle. Moreover, movements like #Girlslikeus as you mentioned have been positive influences though.

    If you feel like reading about how fashion is being promoted via influencers and social media, you can read my paper, link is https://networkconference.netstudies.org/2022/ioa/557/analyzing-the-creative-use-of-social-media-and-influencer-culture-by-fashion-brands-such-as-green-fashion-brands-in-building-and-promoting-themselves-and-investigating-the-challeng/#comment-986

    Best,
    Riya

    • Adel Shalan says:

      Hi Riya,
      Thanks for sharing your point of view. Of course all influencers are not bad people or have harmful intentions. My argument is that it is dangerous the amount of power they have in their hands. I’m asking that we create awareness so people have a better understanding of all the schemes influencers are pulling off.

  7. Michael D'Costa says:

    Hi Adel

    This paper was thought provoking and raises the question of how much of a popular influence social media influencers and celebrities make on our society. I do agree with the sentiment and think that the responsibilities of consuming social media content and influence is not just on the consumer, but the influencer as well. This also may raise the question, how much of this impact can be put on people who have less social media understanding of how influencing works? Are there enough laws around media safety protecting people from the marketing and consumption of content?

    Thank you for the read!

    • Adel Shalan says:

      Hello Michael,
      You asked an important question.
      There are no laws protecting the consumer on social media and with more money being generated from Influencers backed by big organizations like Facebook or Twitter it’s hard to see that happening. I think the main goal is to help those people have a better understanding of marketing schemes and celebrity influence.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>