Abstract
Over the past decade, Web 2.0 has become the medium which allows people to interact with other users online. The websites that exist on the web today, continuously evolve into different platforms and create content and webpage with a purpose of social networking. This encourages communications and discussions to happen among individuals and groups of users on the online platforms. The generated websites avails user to collaborate online, creating new means for individuals to interact with each other and to form communities online. With the emergence of all interactive Social Networking Sites (SNSs), the influence of Web 2.0 as a tool in changing the society is inevitable. The use of SNSs in the social application has also transformed the recruiting industry. In this paper we will focus on the recent development that Web 2.0 has adapted, with LinkedIn as the main SNSs model and discuss the usefulness of the online community that has been built up on LinkedIn for the recruiting industry as well as the effectiveness of LinkedIn as a network growing tool.
Introduction
The rise of Web 2.0 has shifted the technological and sociological paradigm and increased the integrity of our everyday life with the utilization of the Internet. The shift has generated different types of websites and online platforms across the Internet and these websites have become today’s current trend all around the world. Social media platforms are known to be user generated and are characterized with a greater user interactivity, higher engagement rate and user’s collaboration (Mrabet & Triki, 2014). When users are gathered online via the Internet, they communicate with each other and develop a community online. This new way of community development happens through the forum where most online activity and connectivity take place, which’s the Web 2.0 (Fuchs, 2010). The development of these online communities is constructed in different platforms through the services that are available. A virtual community is built under the interaction between users that have the same interest, and their participation in the SNS platforms. Some of the examples of the existing virtual communities are Facebook, WhatsApp, LinkedIn and Skype. These online communities have brought a revolutionary change in many sectors including social and economy aspect. As an example, LinkedIn has resulted in the formation of an online community bringing in a new way of recruiting process and transforming the way network between individuals are built around the globe (Porter, 2015). As the SNSs serves a purpose of connecting people and bringing them together as a community, LinkedIn worked to operate a platform that focuses on businesses-oriented services and has changed the world of HR from the aspects of recruiting industry and the development of the individual’s networking growth.
Web 2.0 and Online Communities
Web 2.0 is known to be the current stage of the development of the Internet which offers reliable connections and avails user interactive platforms to people using a wide range of devices. This has facilitated quick and convenient interactions between people in different locations at any time and bring them together resulting in what is known as an online community (Haythornthwaite & Kendall, 2010). The connectivity being developed between the individuals helps users to participate and collaborate online and this increased internet connectivity has made the world to become a global village. It has become very easy for people who are miles and miles away from each other to interact in real time. This has been enabled by the global internet connectivity and the promotion of the freedom of expression. The connectivity between the users of an SNSs who share a common interest builds up an online community consisting of members who continue to interact with each other on the web driven by the same motives (Porter, 2015). The cost of internet has become highly affordable all over the world especially with the use of fiber optic technology. As a result of these developments, businesses have grown rapidly due to the increased market share, expanded marketing space and reduction in the cost of production. People are using the Internet in ways that drive changes around the community within the emergence of Web 2.0 (Haythornthwaite & Kendall, 2010). Many people today, see Web 2.0 as an opportunity for growth in business and some still see it as a risk that could bring down the social culture. Regardless of the risks, there are more advantages to this development. Online platform such as LinkedIn created an online community adapting web 2.0 as a mean for people to demonstrate their personal skills and build professional network.
LinkedIn in Social Recruitment
LinkedIn is one of the Web 2.0 tools that have brought a greater change in the recruitment industry. Through this platform, the job seekers meet job providers online which makes the recruitment process becomes efficient. Through LinkedIn, professionals in different fields post their profiles which include their academic qualifications, their job experiences and their interests and hobbies. Through this platform, it becomes very simple for some organizations to get their desired professionals which translate to better performance for the business (Dukaric, 2010). Business managers are also able to meet and interact very efficiently with each other. The interactions between users, and the information that are being provided via LinkedIn enables hiring managers to conduct a comparative recruitment and help them in making decision to hire the candidate with the best skills via the Internet and increase the overall performance of the organization. LinkedIn has become a platform which individuals come online to connect with others and is used as a tool to search for new candidates and job openings with a higher rate of success, as it is one of the biggest world’s professional networking site.
The emergence of web 2.0 is known to attain an evolutionary change in the world of recruiting industry. Prior to web 2.0, the first stage of internet (web 1.0) did not facilitate the internet user to participate and contribute on the web because of their “read-only web” system, so people weren’t able to interact with each other online (Wood, 2011). As we all know, our everyday life before the internet existed was slightly more difficult than how it is today. One of the biggest notable change that we can see is the availability of instant access to information which eases the finding of business opportunities and growing connections, allowing people to search, apply for jobs at any time. This couldn’t have been achieved with the traditional recruiting. Before the platform LinkedIn emerged, it was difficult for organizations to identify talented people to work for them. The process was very manual and was not very successful. Many companies used to advertise their vacant potions through the print media which would give room for anyone to apply for the positions. This process was risky since it was possible to employ people who were not well qualified. This situation has been changed by LinkedIn. With LinkedIn, the profession information of an individual is publicly available which makes the recruiters to targets new employees with a great level of accuracy (Cardon, 2007). However, the availability of public information about one’s qualification has its own limitations. One of the greatest challenges is that the information presented by an individual in his or her profile could be misleading. It is not very likely that a person can talk about their limitations. This could at times results in recruiters obtaining false information from the platform, which is something that could be detected earlier when a face to face selection for recruiting is held.
Networking on LinkedIn
LinkedIn allows their users to maintain a close list of connection and encourages people to expand their networks from finding people that are on their connection list (Dukaric, 2010). The network that is being built on the users’ profile can grow very widely and consist not only friends that they already know, but also their 2nd degree of connections (their friend’s connections) and go as far to their 3rd degree of connections (the connections of their connections). These connections that are being displayed can build up trust for the potential business partners to work with each other as they are recommended from someone trustworthy. This feature accommodates individuals to search for jobs opportunities online and can help to create new connections with others in a much easier way (Dukaric, 2010). Users can maintain their connection and invite other people to join their connection list. Although people are allowed to connect widely, the privacy guidelines still respect the users as all connections to be made on LinkedIn must be confirmed by each individuals and profiles of the users will only appear after the approval. LinkedIn as an SNS provides a platform and the tools for people to interact and connect with each other, building up an online community of professional workers around the globe. It can be said that the platform is being used for “networking” just as much as other social media platforms, but its main focus is to build a platform for people’s career and to form business connections.
People often use SNS such as Facebook to share their opinion and come together as groups creating an online community with the motive to socialize, whereas LinkedIn is used to grow people’s connection and with the purpose of finding new professional networks. Chang, Liu and Shen (2017) argued that people motivation of using LinkedIn differ to their motives on using other SNSs. While people use Facebook to locate, share and communicate with their friends, LinkedIn is used for group activities, self-promotion, work and job-related issues. LinkedIn also offers the ability for their users to expand network online within a broader context. Users are able to locate people from around the world and find the proper candidate for a specific task or job description with no restriction. With the number of different SNSs dominating the internet today, each one of the SNS has their own purpose and attract users differently. SNSs such as LinkedIn and Facebook attract their own group of users who came along with different motivations, type of engagement and different perception of usage (Chang, Liu & Shen 2017). Moreover, LinkedIn is considered as a successful SNS as it has gathered users from around the globe, creating an online community with a large number of users. LinkedIn as an online community has become one of the largest professional networking platforms with more than 500 million users (Gallant, 2019). They have strategically planned to provide a service that meets the needs of their users (Dippelreiter, 2008). LinkedIn facilitates their member with such sophisticated tool and technology that eases the process for its users to achieve their main purpose of being online and accessing the SNS.
Self-presentation in Online Community
In the world of online community people pay a great deal of attention on how their images are being portrayed online. Performing an identity in social media has been normalised as a flow of social interaction, with people attempt in constructing their identity to fit in their milieu (Pearson, 2009). Just like in other SNSs, people seeking for jobs on LinkedIn strive to present the best version of themselves and many have reconstructed their identity to create a good self-impression. Within this context, individuals construct their identity relating to their relative networking and play with their aspects of the self-presentation. Chiang and Suen (2015) also suggested that job seekers could increase their chances of being recruited by building an optimal presentation of themselves on LinkedIn. LinkedIn users fill up their profile highlighting their specific skills and experiences to create an idealised perception on their professional identity, followed by the statements from their colleagues and clients giving them feedback to reassure their capability to complete their profile. This attempt to manage one self-presentation by controlling the information that is being included on our social media profile is known as the impression management (boyd, 2007). This impression management is done by individuals or group of businesses in hope to create desirable images of themselves and gain employment opportunities or client.
Furthermore, LinkedIn recommends their user to connect their profile with their social media account, which plays an important function in building up their online self-presentation. By linking their profile to other SNS such as Facebook, Instagram and Twitter it builds up credibility and trustworthiness as many employers likes to do a background check on the potential candidate to understand them better in details to their social status, education and vision (Donath & boyd, 2004). The friends and colleague’s connection lists that are being displayed on LinkedIn can influence a recruiter evaluation or draw hiring managers. This public display of connections shows the quality of a person and their status within the community as their connections provide more information about an individual to the profile viewers. For more effectiveness in the recruiting industry, there is a need to use not only one platform but a combination of web 2.0 tools.
The main reason to why people needs to establish the authenticity of the information being provided on their profiles is to enhance truthfulness in the recruitment industry. In most of SNSs today, user’s personal information is being presented publicly (Ridings & Gefen, 2004). This trait poses a great security threat to the owners of the information. There are many instances when such information has been used in potentially dangerous practices such as the impersonation for the purpose of fraud or false identity. Although this may be true, information being displayed for the public on LinkedIn can be managed through the privacy setting and it operates in a way that people could only ‘connect’ with mutual approval. This form of connections formed in LinkedIn builds up a trusted online environment or a community of people trying to create professional network and personal connections (Donath & boyd, 2004).
Conclusion
With the emergence of Web 2.0, technology has changed the way people are interacting with one another, it has made creating a community online possible and has changed the recruiting culture on a global level as recruitment now could be done via the Internet (Wang, 2012). Internet could bring in different and new experiences for people and adapt the technology that is available today to form communities. SNS such as LinkedIn depicts the change internet has brought as it is considered as a valuable tool in today’s recruiting industry. LinkedIn has been among the best online platforms that can be accessed with readily devices such as desktops and mobile phones. With the development of Web 2.0, there has been a creation of good opportunities on the social and economy aspect through the online communities. Users will continue to try to manage their images/profile online. The way LinkedIn users build their profiles and the way they represent themselves help them to determine the types of job and the opportunities they will get. As an SNS, LinkedIn successfully connects individuals with each other and businesses with their current or future potential partner within the online community.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
References
boyd, D. (2007). Why Youth (Heart) Social Network Sites: The Role of Networked Publics in Teenage Social Life. In D. Buckingham (Ed.), MacArthur Foundation Series on Digital Learning Youth, Identity, and Digital Media Volume. Cambridge, MA.: MIT Press. Retrieved from
http://www.danah.org/papers/WhyYouthHeart.pdf
Cardon, C. A. (2007). An Attempt to Understand the Meaning of Web 2.0. Communications and strategies, 52-65.
Chang, S. E., Liu, A. Y., & Shen, W. C. (2017). User trust in social networking services: A comparison of Facebook and LinkedIn. Computers in Human Behavior, Vol.69, 207-217. Retrieved from https://www-sciencedirect-com.dbgw.lis.curtin.edu.au/science/article/pii/S0747563216308330
Chiang, Johannes K., & Hung-Yue Suen. (2015). Self-presentation and hiring recommendations in online communities: Lessons from LinkedIn. Computers in Human Behavior, Vol. 48, 516-524. Retrieved from https://www-sciencedirect-com.dbgw.lis.curtin.edu.au/science/article/pii/S0747563215001156#!
Dipplereiter, B., Grun, C., Pottler, M., Seidel, I., Berger, H., Dittenbach, M., & Pesenhofer, A. (2008). Online Tourism Communities on the Path to Web 2.0: An Evaluation. Information Technology & Tourism, 10(4), 329-253. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/220542850_Online_Tourism_Communities_on_the_Path_to_Web_20_An_Evaluation
Donath, J., & boyd, D. (2004). Public Displays of Connection. BT Technology Journal, 22(4), 71-82. Retrieved from https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1031348
Dukaric, R. (2010). LinkedIn: Online community research. Social Web Course. Retrieved from https://people.eng.unimelb.edu.au/vkostakos/courses/socialweb10F/projects/2009.linkedin.paper.pdf
Fuchs, C. (2010). Social software and web 2.0: their sociological foundations and implications. In Handbook of research on web 2.0, 3.0 and X.0: technologies, business, and social applications. Volume II, ed. San Murugesan, 764-789. Hershey, PA: IGI- Global. Retrieved from http://fuchs.uti.at/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/Web2.pdf
Gallant, J. (2019). 48 Eye-Opening LinkedIn Statistics for B2B Marketers in 2019. Retrieved from https://foundationinc.co/lab/b2b-marketing-linkedin-stats/
Haythornthwaite, C., & Kendall, L. (2010). Internet and Community. American Behavioral Scientist, 53(8), 1083-1094. DOI: 10.1177/0002764209356242
Mrabet, R. G., & Triki, A. (2014). The use of web 2.0 and online virtual communities to develop marketing strategies, Information and Communication Technologies Innovation and Application (ICTIA). Retrieved from https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7883759
Pearson, E. (2009). All the world web’s stage: The performance of identity in online social networks. First Monday, 14(3). Retrieved from https://firstmonday.org/article/view/2162/2127
Porter, C. E. (2015). Virtual communities and social networks. In L. Cantoni and J. A. Danowski, (eds). Communication and Technology. Berlin: De Gruyter. pp. 161 – 179.
Ridings, C. M,, & Gefen, D. (2004). Virtual Community Attraction: Why People Hang out Online. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communicatio, 10(1), 00-00. Retrieved from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1083-6101.2004.tb00229.x
Wang, K. Y. (2012). Mixing Metaphors: Sociological and Psychological Perspectives on Virtual Communities. In H. Li (Ed.), Virtual Community Participation and Motivation: Cross-Disciplinary Theories (pp. 1-17). Hershey, PA: IGI Global. doi:10.4018/978-1-4666-0312-7.ch001
Wood, B. A. (2011). Using Web 2.0 technologies to build communities:Bridgetown, Barbados: Libraries in Central America and the Caribbean Region —.
Thanks so much for writing this paper! As a supporter of LinkedIn and the way it has evolved, I found this paper to provide an interesting insight from the perspective of an employer/recruiter. I have previously research LinkedIn from the perspective of B2B marketing – where businesses post content (either in the form of re-sharing posts/articles and commenting on them, or posting their own articles using the new blogging article interface), in order to attract potential businesses or individual customers. Which is a very contrasting perspective to recruitment, so I was struck with some new ideas when reading through your essay!
I was interested to know what your thoughts were on the content creating function of LinkedIn, as it relates to your recruitment perspective. Specifically, the function that allows users to create an article relevant to their industry. Do you believe observing what content an individual posts, could help recruiters?
More specifically (and directly relevant to your paper):
Could the articles an individual posts on LinkedIn, offer a more trustworthy insight for employers?
Could this help reinforce a more accurate representation of the individual’s identity, and help clear up some misleading information?
Also, with regard to your insight into how LinkedIn helps people network, do you think articles/re-sharing and commenting on posts, could act as a conversation starter?
Sorry for all the questions! Your paper did indeed spark a lot of thought!
Thanks, and I look forward to reading what you think.
Miranda
Hi Miranda, thanks so much for reading my paper! I’m glad you found it thought-provoking. I’m glad you’ve asked these questions because it has provided me with an opportunity to think deeper about the topics you’ve raised.
In response to your questions regarding articles, posts and content sharing being able to provide insights or more accurate representations of identity I feel like it really depends on the goals of the individual. For someone who is wishing to present themselves in a particular way, this type of interactivity with LinkedIn profiles and content does serve to boost their presentation, for sure. But it definitely goes both ways. By that I mean it could serve to further both their inauthentic and authentic representations of self, depending on their goals. For example, someone who wants to be perceived as a social media influencer would like, share, comment and create content that has the desired effect on their audience and they are able to do so without too many background checks for authenticity.
I believe that recruiters wishing to fill roles by hiring LinkedIn members should be first conducting interviews and following that up with activities that will confirm or deny the facts outlined within that interview – like checking references.
Regarding your question about LinkedIn being a forum for conversation starters – absolutely! There are fewer platforms openly accessible that can provide a forum for business-type conversations for all kinds of people, no matter how far from business-type they might be. So this is a real positive of the platform.
Thanks,
Ces
Hello,
I really enjoyed reading your paper and thought you made a lot of good points! LinkedIn has definitely transformed the recruitment industry and is allowing people to find jobs easier then ever before as it allows for communities and networks to be formed effortlessly. However, do you think that it could be a disadvantage for recruiters as job seekers are so easily able to lie about important information such as their experience and skills?
Feel free to check out my paper: https://networkconference.netstudies.org/2019Curtin/2019/05/03/under-the-influence-social-media-influencers-and-their-role-in-impacting-millennials-travel-decisions/
Hi SFurfaro!
Sorry for the late reply. Thank you so much for spending time to read my paper and thanks for agreeing with the points that I have made. I think the purpose of social media is for people to connect with others and expand their connections, as this process of socialising doesn’t happen face-to-face it is natural that with the tools that are available, people will try to manage their impression and reconstruct their self-presentation. To answer your question, yes I do think that it might be a disadvantage for recruiters if they’re not careful that they will receive false information regarding an individual. However, it can be sorted by carefully running a background check of the other social media profiles that is connected to the LinkedIn profile, as well as conducting a direct interview.
– SAdam
Hi SAdam,
This is an awesome paper! I really like your positive approach towards LinkedIn and how it creates an online community – this is a perspective I hadn’t really considered.
Whilst I do understand your argument suggesting that LinkedIn is a successful recruitment platform due to the advancements of the internet and web 2.0, however I think it is important to think about how much of an impact issues like impression management can actually have – it does not only involve leaving out information from profiles but it can also involve lying about certain aspects that results in inauthentic profiles.
My paper focuses on LinkedIn and how issues such as impression management and online self-presentation on a job-related networking platform can effect how successful the recruitment process is in an online environment. Feel free to check it out https://networkconference.netstudies.org/2019Curtin/2019/05/05/the-inauthenticity-of-professional-self-presentation-in-online-profiles-and-the-effects-on-job-recruitment/
Hi there SAdam,
Just finished reading your paper, and I really enjoyed it! I like that you take an open and positive approach when exploring LinkedIn, as many papers I’ve read on similar topics are quick to throw a negative light on it. I think your paper adds value to the Web 2.0 and communities stream, especially due to the fact you investigate the effect on one particular platform which I think shows an in-depth analysis.
I had never considered the point you make about LinkedIn creating a community, and I completely agree that Web 2.0 has allowed many platforms to transform from networks into communities. Do you think LinkedIn was originally created with the idea that it would eventually transform from a network into a community? Or do you think this is something that happened naturally for users? Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on this.
My paper is also about how Web 2.0 affected our online communities, specifically how it affected communities and activism. Feel free to check it out – https://networkconference.netstudies.org/2019Curtin/2019/05/05/web-2-0-effect-on-societys-engagement-with-activism
Hi there,
Thank you for your feedback. I’m really glad that you have enjoyed reading my paper! I understand that there are different perspectives of the negative and positive sides regarding the use of social media such as LinkedIn and other SNSs that we use daily.
To start off with, this paper was inspired by my personal experience in using LinkedIn as well as the stories on how it has helped my friends expose theirselves out there to get hired and help them grow network. So I really think that although LinkedIn has some of its negative side it is also considered to be one of the successful SNSs platform which means a lot of people has used the platform for their networking purpose (Gallant, 2019). From these successful SNSs, a big number of users are gathered and often it allows the development of online communities to happen just like what you have stated.
You have raised a very interesting question regarding the online community development on LinkedIn. I believe that LinkedIn was originally created with the purpose of the creation of a platform which provides a place for people to build networks with each other, hence the platform itself was designed specifically for business community to grow. However, to think of the question from my own perspective, I don’t think many people signed up for LinkedIn and use the service with the idea to join a community in mind but rather to build up a profile where users can develop a strong digital footprint and expand their networks within the business industry. So what do you think? does that make the process of community development to be natural? I’d love to hear your thoughts on this too!
Thanks,
Syifa
Ref.
Gallant, J. (2019). 48 Eye-Opening LinkedIn Statistics for B2B Marketers in 2019. Retrieved from https://foundationinc.co/lab/b2b-marketing-linkedin-stats/
Hi there,
Thank you for your interesting and insightful paper, it definitely gave me a lot to think about! I was particularly interested by your points about other social media, and how they contribute to showing a rounded image for a person, in conjunction with linkedin. I do not use Linkedin , but if i did my instinct would be to NOT link it to my personal Facebook, for example. I know you point out that linking your socials shows transparency and trustworthiness, but do you think it can also lead to context-collapse? Do you think there should be a separation between public and private profiles?
Thanks for your thoughts!
Hi S Adam,
Engaging paper on a topic that interesting to know more about. I like how you outlined that Linkedin is like an SNS, however, used in a more professional circumstance such as self-promotion and work/job-related issues. I also found it interesting that you pointed out people re-construct their identity to present the best version of themselves and present a desirable image of themselves so that they can gain employment opportunities or a client. Similar to SFurfaro’s curiosity, do you think that many people lie about their skills and are able to create a false identity to due to the free of the use of this platform? Do you know if there are any privacy policies and background checks put in place to spot this? Would like to hear your take on this.
Kind Regards,
Zane Kelly
This was such a great read! It’s so interesting to create a resume in an online sphere because you really are presenting yourself as a brand. Have you heard of those Tinder but for companies where companies can match and unmatch you based on your qualifications? Not sure if its creepy or productive but I guess that’s just the kind of world we live in now.