Building Learning Communities: Social Media’s Influence & Impact on Education Through Video Sharing Platforms

Posted on

by


Thesis Statement
The consistent use of social media, specifically video sharing platforms, is influencing educational communities and has the potential to have even more influence in the future.

Abstract
Through this conference paper, the main idea is to point out the effect and role of social media, such as video sharing platforms, in the educational environment. It looks into the process of a thorough review of the relevant literature, texts, and news articles on this matter and how these tools are creating and transforming educational practices and communities of learning. The review contains implications of good and bad impacts for educational purposes, as well as future forecasts of social media and video sharing platforms in education. This study attempts to give a review that looks at the use of these platforms within the learning context, demonstrating their importance in disseminating information, providing a forum for collaboration, and giving solutions to problems such as misinformation and privacy concerns. This conference paper analyses a range of perspectives and evidence from scholarly research, media reports, and relevant articles with the intention of enlightening readers and is in favour of a fuller understanding of the interaction between social media, video sharing platforms, and education, which is used in researching and making future discussions on this issue.

Introduction
Social media has massively influenced different education systems from all across the world. The growth of social media has had a significant impact on higher education. Sewlyn (2012) states that social media being integrated into education has impacted the nature of the students entering into universities. The collective and creative, highly connected and creative aspects of social media are seen as much more flexible and fluid in our daily lives. As a result of the positive aspects that social media withholds, social media can be accredited for the increases in the tendencies for young people to multi task and use skills such as ‘digital juggling’ to take on daily tasks and commitments (Subrahmanyam & Šmahel, 2011, as cited by Sewlyn, 2012). Additionally, educators are aware of the incoming cohort of students entering universities who spent a lot of time on the internet. As a result, Universities are now using social networking sites such as Facebook to connect with students and have more interactions among students. (Mason & Rennie, 2007, as cited by Sewlyn, 2012). In fact, in 2014, The University of Melbourne became Australia’s first University to open a snapchat account with the intention of familiarising students with the campus (Driessen 2017). As social media begins to influence education systems, the use of video sharing platforms has increased across the globe. The COVID-19 pandemic saw a rise in the use of video sharing technology. Video sharing platforms such as Zoom saw a rise in usage from 40% to 100% in 2020 (Brascombe, 2020, as cited by De et.al, 2020). YouTube was found to have the most significant growth among American users during the pandemic, from 73% of American adults in 2019 to 91% in 2021. Other online communities, such as Reddit, saw a small rise in popularity as its usage went from 11% in 2019 to 18% in 2021 (Rodriguez, 2021). Due to the closure of universities, institutions had to rely on services such as Zoom and YouTube which saw universities refund students for parking, housing, and dining (Aratini, 2020). With the increasing use of social media in educational environments, this study aims to explore the impact & influences that video sharing platforms have on educational communities, exploring both the positive and negative impacts of the digital takeover. The rise of social media in an educational context has significantly impacted classrooms. The integration of social media into classrooms has improved information flow, peer connections, and self regulated learning (Kai et.al 2017, Kimmerle et.al 2017, Neuman and Hood 2009, Zou et.al, 2016 as cited by Toofaninejhad et.al, 2017). Popular platforms such as Facebook and other collaborative tools have transformed content distribution and teaching methods (Veletsianos and Navvarate, 2012 as cited by Toofaninejhad et.al, 2017). To delve into the impact that social media and video sharing platforms have on education, it is important to explore the existing literature that analyses the relationship with educational outcomes. This review aims to synthesise relevant findings and insights regarding the integration of social media, particularly video sharing platforms, within educational settings. Through the examination of previous studies and discussions, this review seeks to highlight the direct impact that video sharing platforms have on education communities across the world.

Effectively integrated across different educational institutions
Video sharing platforms have had a significant positive impact on educational communities. YouTube, a video sharing platform with billions of users, is being used as a learning tool in classrooms across the world. YouTube offers a variety of different learning opportunities. YouTube has engaged with their “how-to” tutorials covering a variety of different subjects (Almobarraz, 2018, as cited by Khan et.al, 2023). The use of YouTube has varied across many fields of education. The medical education institutions have found that educators have effectively used YouTube videos in their lessons, the use of YouTube videos for teaching language and literature in Saudi colleges, visual explanations from video platforms such as YouTube offer has greatly improved the understanding and retention of complex concepts (Jaffar, 2012, Burke SC 2009, Rapp et.al 2016, Chtouki et.al 2014 as cited by Khan et.al 2023). Khan et.al (2023) conducted an inferential qualitative survey amongst students from Kohat University with the intended purpose of exploring the significance of YouTube in education and communities. The participants in the survey (students) had different levels of education including: Bachelors, Masters, M.Phil, PHD. The results of the study found that, combined, 97% of students either strongly agreed or simply agreed that students watch YouTube for educational purposes. 67.5% of students strongly agreed that YouTube is a good platform that provides good learning opportunities & study material, with 29% of students strongly agreeing with this notion. 72.5% believe that YouTube videos can help students learn more rapidly, demonstrating a widespread belief that YouTube is a useful tool for knowledge acquisition. Khan et. al (2023) also demonstrate that instructors uploading lectures to YouTube is useful for students, 96% of students believe that YouTube videos uploaded by lecturers are helpful for students for a longer period of time.YouTube isn’t the only video sharing platform that has positively impacted educational communities. TikTok, another video sharing platform, has over 4.5 billion downloads. Released in 2016, TikTok is an app that allows users to create, watch, and share short videos on mobile devices and webcams (D’Souza 2024). Similarly to YouTube, TikTok has been used in educational institutions and, as a result, has enhanced learning in classrooms. Yang (2020) conducted a study amongst 187 Chinese secondary students from 7th to 12th grade in a voluntary quantitative survey to understand how TikTok can be used to assist in English learning. Results from the survey found that a vast majority of the students had a positive attitude towards the use for TikTok in the classroom. It was found that despite the different grades of the students, the vast majority of them held positive attitudes towards TikTok and saw it as a great tool to enhance their understanding of the English language.

Distracting and Misguiding Students & Impacting Mental Health and Learning
Despite the many benefits that video sharing platforms have on educational institutions, they can negatively impact educational communities and environments. Video sharing platforms can easily distract students as much as they engage them. Mekler (2021) found that among 111 students aged 18-28 who spent a lot of time on TikTok, they became increasingly more distracted and lost track of time, indicating that the popularity of this app is slowing down students’ attention spans. Qamariah (2023) also acknowledges the distraction that video sharing platforms can have on students, pointing out the many entertainment features that YouTube possesses that could potentially distract students from their initial intention of learning. Qamariah (2023) argues that because Youtube has no filtration system when it comes to uploading content, some video creators may not provide good, accurate learning. As a result, inaccurate and unreliable content can be produced. Kamal et.al (2023) conducted interviews among 18-23 year olds who had basic knowledge of internet use, were currently enrolled in university, had previous experience using YouTube, and had an interest in entertainment channels. Participants acknowledged the harmful effects of certain content on YouTube, acknowledging the fact that content creators can influence others to imitate such content without realising the harmful effects of it. Such concerns have been taken seriously around the world, resulting in legal action. Eric Adams, the New York City Mayor, filed a lawsuit against the parent companies of TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat, and YouTube. The reason behind the Adam’s administration’s legal action against these platforms is their alleged affect on the mental health of children (The Guardian, 2024). Beyond just providing distractions and false information, video sharing platforms can have detrimental effects on educational groups. The possibility of increasing passive learning and decreasing student participation is one major worry. Over-reliance on video content can impair pupils’ capacity for independent information analysis and weaken their critical thinking abilities (Mayer, 2009). Furthermore, learners may get confused and educational content inconsistent as a result of the availability of videos from multiple sources (Bates & Sangrà, 2011). Furthermore, the prioritisation of entertainment value over instructional quality resulting from the privatisation of education through monetization on video platforms may lead to superficial learning experiences (Veletsianos, 2018). These problems show how crucial it is to balance the use of video content with interactive and participatory learning techniques in order to help students develop deeper comprehension and critical thinking abilities.

Potential To Revolutionize Learning Spaces
Video sharing platforms have the potential to revolutionise learning spaces of the future by ensuring easy access to endless associated informative content for students all over the world (Darby, 2019). Learners can interact with the relevant information to them, in the right format to efficiently motivate them, enabling them to gain a strong grasp on and retain concepts that fit their specific needs and preferences (Bonk & Khoo, 2014). Video sharing platforms also facilitate a sense of peers and community in education, as they create a peerless collaborative online learning space for teachers and students to interact in real-time (Kimmons & Veletsianos, 2018). Platforms can act as valuable tools for teacher professional development, as educators can be furnished with training materials and instructional resources to which they can access anytime, anywhere (Saka, 2020). The integration of video in learning provides for a collaborative learning setting which enhances the application of innovative pedagogical approaches, such as flipped classrooms and a multitude of other blended learning models (Brame, 2013). Additionally, video sharing platforms support a modern educational system by accommodating all kinds of interests as well as unique learning demands, enabling learners to expand their learning even in spaces outside the classroom and embark on lifelong learning and skill development amidst the changing demands of the world.

Conclusion
The consistent use of video sharing platforms is currently influencing educational communities and has the potential to continue in the future. Video sharing platforms such as YouTube and Zoom have seen an increase in popularity during the COVID 19 pandemic, particularly among universities, as a method to educate students off campus. The integration of video sharing platforms has had positive effects on many educational institutions around the world. The many features that YouTube and TikTok possess have been utilised in classrooms in Saudi Arabia and China for skills such as language and literature. Students with different educational backgrounds all seemed to believe YouTube was beneficial for their learning. However, the impact that video sharing platforms have isn’t always positive. Platforms such as TikTok have been found to be distracting for students due to their engaging and addictive nature. This was particularly present among students who spent a lot of their time on social media. Video sharing platforms easily distribute information across the world, however, due to platforms such as YouTube having no filtration systems or qualification requirements needed to post educational content, students can easily be exposed to misinformation. The popularity of video sharing platforms can also influence youth to imitate harmful behaviours without understanding the harmful consequences these behaviours can cause. Despite their large presence in education institutions across the world, video sharing platforms continue to have the potential to impact learning spaces. Video platforms enable learners to access content that’s relevant to them, as well as continuing the trend of a collaborative online space between teachers and students. Video sharing platforms support the modern day education system due to the fact that there is so much content that appeals to so many different interests enabling learning spaces beyond the classroom.

References

Ahmad Julianto, & Zaitun Qamariah. (2023). A Literature Study On The Negative Impact Of Youtube As An English Language Learning Media. Atmosfer: Jurnal Pendidikan, Bahasa, Sastra, Seni, Budaya, Dan Sosial Humaniora, 1(3), 182–193. https://doi.org/10.59024/atmosfer.v1i3.232



Aratani, L. (2020). ‘Zoom University’: is college worth the cost without the in-person experience? The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/06/zoom-university-college-cost-students-in-person-experience

Bates, A. W., & Sangrà, A. (2011). Managing technology in higher education: Strategies for transforming teaching and learning. John Wiley & Sons.
https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118269558


Bonk, C. J., & Khoo, E. G. (2014). Adding Some TEC-VARIETY: 100+ Activities for Motivating and Retaining Learners Online. OpenWorldBooks.com.
https://www.academia.edu/7184346/_Free_Book_and_Free_Chapters_Bonk_C_J_and_Khoo_E_2014_Adding_Some_TEC_VARIETY_100_Activities_for_Motivating_and_Retaining_Learners_Online_OpenWorldBooks_com_and_Amazon_CreateSpace

Brame, C. J. (2013). Flipping the classroom. Vanderbilt University Center for Teaching. https://cft.vanderbilt.edu/guides-sub-pages/flipping-the-classroom/

Darby, F. (2019). Small Teaching Online: Applying Learning Science in Online Classes. Jossey-Bass.
10.1556/063.2020.00039

De’R, Pandey N, Pal A. (2020). Impact of digital surge during Covid-19 pandemic: A viewpoint on research and practice. International Journal of Information Management, 55, 102171
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0268401220309622?via%3Dihub

Driessen, B. (2017). The power of social media in education. PwC Australia. Retrieved from: https://www.pwc.com.au/digitalpulse/social-media-higher-education.html

Johnson, L., & Adams Becker, S. (2015). NMC Horizon Report: 2015 Higher Education Edition. The New Media Consortium.
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED559357.pdf

Khan, A., Saeed, M., Anwar, M. N., & Kanwal, L.* (2023). Unleashing the Potential: A Study of the Effectiveness and Impact of YouTube Educational Content on Student Learning Outcomes.
https://www.hilarispublisher.com/open-access/unleashing-the-potential-a-study-of-the-effectiveness-and-impact-of-youtube-educational-content-on-student-learning-outcomes-101464.html#22

Kimmons, R., & Veletsianos, G. (2018). Education scholars’ evolving uses of Twitter as a conference backchannel and social commentary platform. British Journal of Educational Technology, 49(3), 392–401.
https://doi.org/10.1111/bjet.12551

Mayer, R. E. (2009). Multimedia learning (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511811678


Search Site

Your Experience

We would love to hear about your experience at our conference this year via our DCN XV Feedback Form.

Comments

10 responses to “Building Learning Communities: Social Media’s Influence & Impact on Education Through Video Sharing Platforms”

  1. Scarlett Grimwood Avatar
    Scarlett Grimwood

    Hello o/

    I really like your paper Rueben! I don’t know why anyone hasn’t read it sooner, it’s such an important topic and directly relevant to all of us. Lectures have steadily decreased in length over my short time at university, and I often watch them as recordings instead of live anyway. There’s a lot of videos online that are concise and informative and often better at conveying information than traditional teaching methods. As you said though, there’s a lot of misinformation online and not that much effort from platforms to stop it.

    Do you think platforms like YouTube and TikTok will ever try to prevent the spread of misinformation without external influence (such as government policy)? There’s new platforms that have been founded on producing high quality, factual video content such as Curiosity Stream but existing social media hasn’t seemed to make any attempts to moderate the accuracy of the content on their sites. There’s clearly interest and money in the sector, do you have any idea why that might be the case?

    1. Reuben Cunningham Avatar
      Reuben Cunningham

      Hi Scarlett!

      I’m very happy to hear that you enjoyed reading my paper, it’s nice to receive such a positive comment. I’m very happy to see that you’ve noticed that rise of video platforms changing our education system, you really understood the basis of my argument where I argue for both positive and negative aspects.

      As for your question, unfortunately, I haven’t seen much of an effort from YouTube to stop the spread of misinformation. I’ve seen a little bit from TikTok but they’re currently under attack for taking down all sorts of content so I don’t necessarily think it’s a way to de-platform those who spread misinformation. I suppose the reason behind this is potentially laziness on their part, they seem to only care about money and taking down some forms of hate speech rather than blatant misinformation. It’s a topic that certainly needs more studying as to why there’s so much misinformation.

      Do you think the digital takeover is good for education systems?

      1. Scarlett Grimwood Avatar
        Scarlett Grimwood

        Honestly, I don’t think so. It is SUCH a good idea, and the wider accessibility of information is an amazing thing, but these existing platforms just aren’t designed for education. It’s not something I have a statistic for, but I know that the “education and learning” space on YouTube has been complaining for a long time now. There are hundreds of channels that provide genuine, high quality information that is engaging and easy to understand, and they’re being overshadowed in performance by channels that post multiple videos a day, every day, often to multiple channels. “Five minute crafts” is a style of content that gets millions of views on YouTube, and pushed by the algorithm, but is of low quality and often completely false. I’ve watched a fair share of videos “debunking” that kind of content, but it is never removed.

        YouTube is a content platform, it’s just not designed for it. I imagine TikTok is the same. These platforms value frequency, engagement and relevancy over anything else. Educational content at its best is slower to produce, garners a smaller audience and is timeless, it’s not what these platforms promote.

        We’ve seen some creators from platforms like YouTube create their own platforms dedicated to learning because they just didn’t feel appreciated there. Do you foresee universities like Curtin partnering with platforms like YouTube more formally over time, or creating their own video content spaces?

        1. Reuben Cunningham Avatar
          Reuben Cunningham

          Yeah I 100% agree. I am aware of 5 minute craft and I find my self seriously frustrated over their blatant misinformation! I think such platforms really need to stop overshadowing genuine information for engagement and numbers. Quite frankly it’s selfish and it’s destroying the beauty of such platforms.

          As for your question, I think it would be great if Curtin started a legitimate partnership with YouTube to possibly educate wider audiences, however, I would prefer if they created their own video content space so that qualified individuals hired by the University can spread proven information instead of distributing misinformation like a lot of video sharing platforms do.

  2. dylanbradshaw Avatar
    dylanbradshaw

    Hey Reuben
    Enjoyed the paper, especially that on how a lack of creditationals from educators can lead to misinformation and if you were go to an extreme viewing, damaging the progress of a student. Conflicting viewpoints from these online teachers and a students’ actual teacher can lead students to become frustrated with their educational as methods of attaining an answer can vary.

    You mentioned that how this new tech can lead to passive learners but my question to you is can this new technology lead to passive teaching in which a teacher will just place a Youtube video on the screen and sit back and collect their cash. Destroying the positive aspects of teaching such as having social interaction with students. Personally my fondest memories of learning in high school was clarifying with a teacher or having a joke with them. They are far more likely to answer your unique question rather than a vast generalisied asnwer a Youtube video may give you.

    Being told to pay attention is a teacher’s favourite catchphrase, however on a computer a student can simply walk away and go play Xbox for their hour session and wiggle their mouse from time to time. How can we ensure that learners stay proactive in their learning. Of course having video cameras on is a used method but is still not enforced that much. Is it by making more active lessons such as a pop quiz every ten minutes?

    Overall, i really enjoyed reading your paper and if you could, read mine on Community disruption and how they bond after facing adversity.

    1. Reuben Cunningham Avatar
      Reuben Cunningham

      Hi Dylan,

      Thank you for your valuable feedback I really appreciate it. I love the points you have raised about misinformation as I feel that is super important and I’m glad you’ve resonated with that. You’ve asked me a very valid question about passive learning. I believe that teachers should utilise YouTube videos without using digital creators to do their jobs for them, they should combine YouTube videos and their own teaching methods to create a better learning environment for students.

      I believe that a healthy balanced classroom is amazing for students, especially how you appreciate teachers sharing jokes and having a connection with children. However, when it comes to complicated topics with a lot of nuances, such as learning a new language as mentioned in my paper, videos from the internet can assist in a way a teacher potentially cannot.

      I personally really enjoyed pop quizzes so I do love your suggestion.

      Regards,
      Reuben

  3. Angus Avatar
    Angus

    Hey Reuben,

    Your exploration of the impact of video-sharing platforms like YouTube and TikTok on education is certainly insightful. I feel you have skillfully combined data and anecdotes to highlight the challenges but also how these platforms can be beneficial to learning environments. It is compelling how these platforms can foster collaborative online learning spaces.

    I’m curious about whether you believe there are specific strategies that can be employed to maximize the positive aspects of these platforms while minimizing the negative impacts you’ve outlined. Additionally, given the rapid progression of digital technology, what are your predictions for the integration of video-sharing platforms in traditional educational settings?

    – A

    1. Reuben Cunningham Avatar
      Reuben Cunningham

      Hi Angus,

      I have a very interesting solution to your question however I feel that it’s likely to going to cause controversy amongst the YouTube education community. I think that if we use some sort of peer review system that we use to determine the credibility of studies, we could use that to possibly filter misinformation.

      YouTube should hire thousands of fact checkers the same way X does, to delete videos that share misinformation. YouTube should then have a peer reviewed tag next to a educational YouTube video to show viewers that this video is 100% misinformation free. Any channels that consistently spread misinformation can eventually be banned from the site. I also think that there should be some sort of verification badge dedicated to educators to give audiences and creators credibility for their efforts.

      Some may argue that this will stop income from smaller creators who can’t access their verification badge due to their small channels. However, I think this is for the greater good because it will give YouTube credibility, create more jobs and filter misinformation out for global education communities.

      1. Angus Avatar
        Angus

        Hi Reuben,

        Thank you for the thoughtful ideas you shared, it is an intriguing system that I think definitely could help ensure that educational content remains accurate and reliable. I can see how introducing such a system might be controversial within the YouTube education community, especially for smaller creators perhaps with less backing than the larger “SciShow” channels of the world. Balancing content quality and supporting emerging creators definitely would be a challenge. I also really like your suggestion of implementing a solution similar to X’s model by hiring fact checkers. It seems like this could significantly enhance the YouTube’s integrity.

        – A

  4. Nemat Almonjed Avatar
    Nemat Almonjed

    Hi Reuben,

    I got an advice from Angus to read your paper as it’s very interesting and have similar subject to my paper, and honestly Angus was right, your paper examined the Social Media’s influence over eduction just on point and I really enjoyed.

    your paper provides a comprehensive analysis of how video sharing platforms affect learning communities. It presents a balanced viewpoint and appropriately draws attention to both the amazing and awful aspects. The claims are supported by a comprehensive analysis of multiple studies and cases. All in all, it provides invaluable insights into the challenges of incorporating social media into educational environments and the need for rigorous analysis of its consequences.

    Thanks

Leave a Reply

Skip to content