Negative impacts of online education.

Posted on

by


The use of social media for educational purposes is widespread throughout the world and has become an essential part of daily human communication. The COVID-19 pandemic epidemic drove people all over the world to adopt online education using a variety of digital tools, including social media as a crucial component in the learning process. However, there were issues with social media use for a number of things, including internet services, students’ and teachers’ information and communication technology abilities, integrity, and assurance of educational quality. All aspects of society were impacted by the COVID-19 outbreak because people were instructed to self-quarantine in their houses to stop the virus’s spread. The lockdown has negative effects on mental health, leading to issues including despair, tension, and frustration.

As China entered the era of social media on smartphones, the COVID-19 epidemic, a recent serious public health emergency, was the country’s first big health emergency. According to this survey, many people on social media asked for assistance with quarantines. Prior research on social media use during the pandemic tended to concentrate more on people’s emotional needs and less on content related to quarantine help-seeking. Based on this circumstance, this study used Zhihu, China’s most comprehensive subject discussion forum, to investigate the relationship between the number of postings asking for help with quarantine and the number of new diagnoses at various stages of the epidemic. Those that make requests for assistance on Zhihu come from a variety of backgrounds, occupations, and ages, so the posts’ content is unique and varied. The quantity of posts requesting assistance and the intensity of the epidemic were found to be positively correlated (Li, 2022).

These are different result shown in another survey by Out of 17,876 participants, the mean PA score was 25.5 7.3 while the mean NA score was 19.1 7.1. Multiple linear regression analyses revealed that factors like education, knowledge of communicable diseases, satisfaction with epidemic prevention and control measures, risk of infection, impact of the outbreak on daily life, amount of sleep, and frequency of hand washing in the previous two weeks are common determinants of both positive and negative affect schedules. Moreover, whether the student is majoring in medicine and whether they had been outside in the last two weeks were particular factors of PA, while how often they use masks was a specific determinant of NA (Wang, 2020).

 Given the diversity of people’s help-seeking content, this study used topic model analysis and sentiment analysis to explore the key content of people’s quarantine help-seeking posts during the pandemic. In light of the framework of uses and gratifications, we found that people posted the most questions in relation to help with information related to pandemic information and quarantine information. The survey also discovered that the majority of people’s posts during the pandemic were negative in nature. Additionally, it will support the implementation of future mental health intervention initiatives and better address the psychological issues facing the public.

The virus was not finished with China but also attacked other part of Asia for example Jordan, by of December 20, 2020, there were 3,568 fatalities and 275,000 confirmed cases, according to the Ministry of Health (Ministry of Health, 2020). The COVID-19 epidemic has compelled many nations to issue emergency plans and impose social and public limitations. In order to contain COVID-19, the government proclaimed a state of emergency in the middle of March 2020. This prompted severe quarantine, social, and public health measures, as well as lockdown orders. Online education has become popular among college students. Due to this circumstance, kids who were also under parental pressure to follow public health measures and participate in online learning within the constraints of limited information technology devices experienced burden (Hamaideh, 2018).

This study conducted by Hamaideh (2018) is addressing psychological well-being of university students during a critical global situation; the outbreak of coronavirus that resulted in global lockdown and home quarantine. The study aimed at assessing prevalence and predictors of depression, anxiety and stress among university students in Jordan during “home-quarantine” due to the outbreak of COVID-19. We found that university students are suffering moderate to high level of depression, anxiety and stress which is higher than typical levels in ordinary circumstances. When comparing our results regarding depression, anxiety and stress with results from the general populations from seven middle-income countries (Vietnam, China, Iran, Malaysia, Philippines, Pakistan, and Thailand), higher levels were found among Jordanian students except those among Thailand who have higher levels for depression, anxiety and stress.

However, the Ministry of Health in Jordan has put measures in use to prevent further depressive students, various programs have been put to use such as TeleMHPSS and hotlines where students are encouraged to call for assistance whenever they feel anxious, depressed, or stressed out in order to lessen the psychological distress that students experience during “home-quarantine.” These programs will enable psychiatric nurse practitioners to identify signs of depression, anxiety, or stress early and take appropriate action to stop their development. Also, university administrators ought to give students—including those from abroad—more attention and offer prompt, effective mental health assistance. Moreover, cognitive behavior therapy (CBT), particularly Internet CBT, which can stop the transmission of infection during the pandemic, is the most economical evidence-based treatment for psychological symptoms including insomnia during the COVID-19 pandemic. Moreover, spirituality and religiosity may lessen the emotional tension.

The Corona Virus was a malicious force that subjugated the entire world and it affected every educational departments including medical students, how do we save the world if the saviours are at risk? This study conducted in Libya where thirteen medical schools responded, as lectures and patient-based education are both based on lectures (Alsoufi, 2020), the highly contagious nature of the virus has made it challenging to carry on with business as normal. Instructors must conduct lectures safely while simultaneously preserving the integrity and continuity of the medical education process because to the COVID-19 pandemic, which puts patients at risk of developing life-threatening diseases. Due to these difficulties, patient care has been constrained because of the emphasis on COVID-19 patients, which limits the opportunity for bedside instruction for medical students.

Developing alternatives has become more important as a result of the disruption to the medical education process. Unfortunately, Libya’s infrastructure has been impacted by its civil conflict and economic catastrophe. Blackouts and unreliable internet connections could thus be a problem for online learning platforms. To analyse their viability and determine whether they are sufficient to support medical students in continuing their study, we must take into account that certain departments have begun offering online lectures for medical students. Consequently, the purpose of this study was to ascertain the knowledge, attitudes, and practices of medical students in relation to digital medical education as well as to present an overview of their conditions throughout the pandemic.

Questionnaires were collected from schools in Libya and the results has been as expected. 3.348 full surveys from more than 13 medical schools in Libya were gathered by our team. Based on the distribution of 4,500 paper questionnaires and communications, the expected response rate was 74%. There were 2,390 female participants (71.4% of the sample), compared to 958 male participants (28.6%). The average participant age was 21.87 years, and there was a sizable mean difference between the genders. With 1,199 completed questionnaires, the University of Tripoli had the greatest response rate (35.8%), followed by the University of Benghazi (448 completed questionnaires, 35.8%) (Alsoufi, 2020).

Medical students in Libya are dealing with a number of issues; 12.8% of them reported being internally displaced from their homes due to the local turmoil that has devastated numerous cities, and 40.5% reported having financial difficulties according to this study.

However there were a few proposals that were considered to give students their study hour without any complications. One of the suggested proposals was to engage in case-specific internet forums. Using this method, students are initially given access to a weekly series of intense online cases that simulate clinical roles. They then offer a review of the patient’s history, findings from the physical examination, outcomes of the investigations, and suggested management regimens via an online platform. The subject is then discussed through an online webinar with a teaching and experienced doctor, and students are given the opportunity to ask questions using a particular online platform.

The usage of telemedicine, which has been present for many years, is another suggested way to address the issues related to medical education. Telemedicine, which involves a virtual visit as opposed to an in-person one, so it can be very beneficial in teaching medical students and assisting them in gaining clinical experience by engaging with real patients while being supervised by attending physicians.

This method was favoured in this study by many schools is Virtual clinics as it may give benefits to patients because it is simple to use and permits connectivity without running the danger of spreading infections. It would be advantageous if doctors’ workloads could be lessened, especially during an outbreak, and if clinicians had the chance to treat patients with severe and chronic diseases. Students gave favourable feedback about a virtual clinical experience that entailed direct involvement in patient care while being supervised by doctors in a recent study on emergency medicine training. However, this strategy needs additional testing, and more backing is required for its official adoption in medical schools.

There are many other proposals received and was implemented in India, Delhi as stated in another study. They proposed that the responsible authorities should continue to invest in online education to improve learning experiences once the COVID-19 outbreak is over and educational facilities reopen. They should carefully consider the difficulties encountered during the abrupt switch to online learning and make plans for any upcoming circumstances. It is necessary to perform proper training for educators in digital abilities and enhance student-teacher engagement. To prevent any interference with their studies, disadvantaged kids must have access to digital infrastructure with reliable internet and devices.

It is essential to offer students emotional assistance because many of them are likely to experience stress, anxiety, and despair as a result of the circumstances in Covid-19. Future research in this area might examine the impact of various stress relievers on students’ mental health. Moreover, policies should be developed to account for the requirements of the vulnerable student population. The provision of mental health support would be ensured by improved healthcare management (Chaturvedi, K. Vishwakarma, Singh, 2020).

There are some limitations to this study that should be noted. We should be aware of various restrictions in this study. The testing method utilized is the first constraint. Selection bias is enhanced by its reliance on volunteer participation and digital infrastructure. The outreach to students who do not have access to online learning was interrupted by the imposed travel restrictions. Second, because the study was conducted in a single locale and because classes were delivered online and under lockdown, we anticipate that the findings will be fairly and directly approached to colleges and universities across the country. The cross-sectional form of the survey and lack of a follow-up period for the participants are further limitations of this study.

The daily lives, academic performance, and mental health of pupils have all been significantly impacted by Covid-19. The Covid-19-related pauses highlight important issues and give a chance to better assess potential solutions in the educational field. The new rules and regulations in this direction would lessen some of the effects and assist educators and students get ready for the coming health catastrophe. Effective solutions are required to lessen this disturbance, and such approaches include online instruction followed by practical practice in a secure setting, however the latter may take some time given the ongoing COVID-19 spread. We have discovered that key factors that need to be addressed and taken care of by mental health nurses and counselors at academic institutions and counseling departments include sleep and food disorders, worry over academic grades, and a sense of loneliness. Teachers and administrators must also offer the right kind of psychological support and refrain from overburdening kids during quarantine periods. The COVID-19 outbreak has a negative impact on college and university students. The COVID-19 outbreak has a negative impact on college and university students. We should improve the positive impact of university and college students while strengthening the direction and regulation for negative affect during the epidemic response.

REFERENCES

Alsoufi, A., Alsuyihili, A., Msherghi, A., Elhadi, A., Atiyah, H., Ashini, A., Ashwieb, A., Ghula, M., Ben Hasan, H., Abudabuos, S., Alameen, H., Abokhdhir, T., Anaiba, M., Nagib, T., Shuwayyah, A., Benothman, R., Arrefae, G., Alkhwayildi, A., Alhadi, A., . . . Elhadi, M. (2020, November 25). Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on medical education: Medical students’ knowledge, attitudes, and practices regarding electronic learning. PLOS ONE, 15(11), e0242905. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0242905

Chaturvedi, K., Vishwakarma, D. K., & Singh, N. (2021, February). COVID-19 and its impact on education, social life and mental health of students: A survey. Children and Youth Services Review, 121, 105866. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2020.105866

Hamaideh, S. H., Al‐Modallal, H., Tanash, M., & Hamdan‐Mansour3, A. (2021, May 14). Depression, anxiety and stress among undergraduate students during COVID‐19 outbreak and “home‐quarantine.” Nursing Open, 9(2), 1423–1431. https://doi.org/10.1002/nop2.918

Makki, A., & Bali, A. O. (2021, May 10). The Use of Social Media as a Platform in Education: Ramifications of COVID-19 in Iraq. Academic Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 10(3), 394. https://doi.org/10.36941/ajis-2021-0093

Li, L., Hua, L., & Gao, F. (2022, December 31). What We Ask about When We Ask about Quarantine? Content and Sentiment Analysis on Online Help-Seeking Posts during COVID-19 on a Q&A Platform in China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 20(1), 780. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20010780

Wang, Y., Jing, X., Han, W. et al. Positive and negative affect of university and college students during COVID-19 outbreak: a network-based survey. Int J Public Health 65, 1437–1443 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00038-020-01483-3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Search Site

Your Experience

We would love to hear about your experience at our conference this year via our DCN XIV Feedback Form.

Comments

19 responses to “Negative impacts of online education.”

  1. natalie.champion Avatar
    natalie.champion

    Hi Divyesh,

    Great job on your paper! A very important and relevant topic.

    I was wondering if the concerns raised in your paper about the effects of COVID on online education would still be valid if the restrictions on COVID were to be lifted.To rephrase, do these problems only arise in the context of COVID, or do they affect all forms of distance learning under normal circumstances?

    Do you think medical students could effectively learn online had COVID not been an issue? Do you think a medical students could effectively learn online in the future?

    Would love to hear your thoughts

    1. Divyesh.Ramloll Avatar
      Divyesh.Ramloll

      Hello Natalie,
      Thanks for the comments.
      I think that medical education cannot be conducted online as the art of saving someone cannot be taught via a screen. I understand what you are trying to say but for me, medical education is on another level than any education.

      1. natalie.champion Avatar
        natalie.champion

        Hi Divyesh!

        Thanks for getting back to me.

        I agree that it requires hands-on experience and a deep understanding of the human body, which cannot be fully grasped through online courses. However, I also believe that technology can play a role in enhancing medical education. Many medical schools have successfully implemented online education and simulations to supplement in-person training. Additionally, the use of technology has allowed for greater accessibility and flexibility for students pursuing medical education. Virtual reality simulations and interactive case studies can provide students with valuable learning experiences that complement their in-person training. Additionally, online resources such as medical journals and databases allow students to stay up-to-date on the latest research and advancements in the field. While online courses may not be able to fully replace in-person training, they can certainly supplement it and help prepare future healthcare professionals for the challenges they will face in their careers. 

        Nat

  2. Cameron.S.James Avatar
    Cameron.S.James

    Interesting paper Divyesh. Just wanted to ask you if you think online learning via telemedicine would actually be that much of a substitute when compared to real life learning. Personally I feel as if medicine students would miss out on vital learning elements such as bedside manners and how patients should be treated but I’m interested to hear what u feel on the subject.

  3. Samuel.Claydon Avatar
    Samuel.Claydon

    Hello Divyesh, thanks for posting your paper! It is very relevant topic for a lot of us, I’m sure.

    As someone who has been studying online for a few years now, it has certainly been harder than I expected it to be. Depression, anxiety, and stress are things that I have experienced more in the last few years than ever before. I think those feelings are compounded by the fact that it is so easy to feel like you’re going through this on your own when you are studying online. Though the institutions I have studied with (RMIT and Curtin) have done a good job of providing aid throughout these troubling times, it has still been tough.

    The idea of training medicine professionals to work in virtual workplaces is interesting. While it would certainly help with ease of access to a doctor, I am sure there are many restrictions when diagnosing the patients condition.

    When I had Covid back in December I was put on a program that meant I had around the clock access to nurses over the phone. They helped me a lot by writing scripts and having nearby pharmacies deliver them to me. However, when the nurses needed to check on my condition there was little they could do other than have me hold the camera up in certain places. Though at the very least I do think that it is a good way for students in training to gain some experience with patients.

    Maybe a system that allows virtual doctors to refer patients to an in-person clinic if needed would be a good idea. It would make typical appointments for refilling scripts much quicker, and free up doctor offices a bit for those that truly need to go.

    What do you think?

    -Sam

    1. Divyesh.Ramloll Avatar
      Divyesh.Ramloll

      Hello Sam,
      Thanks for the comments.
      It is a good point you are implying and it is very possible to conduct appointments online but the drawback will be that doctors with online education will be nervous when they will be in contact with real patients and regular appointments in person will be better as patients would not be able to describe their pain within terms.
      For me, traditional appointments are the best.
      But the idea you proposed can be a revelation.

  4. D.Athukorala Avatar
    D.Athukorala

    Hi Divyesh,

    Great job on providing such an informative and captivating read!

    As I was reading your paper, the thought of online exams administered during the pandemic came to my attention. Despite some exams being conducted online for the sake of convenience, there are concerns about how this may negatively affect the education system as a whole. Can you share your thoughts on this matter?

  5. Kevin.Isler Avatar
    Kevin.Isler

    Hi there,

    A really great paper, well-executed and researched. The concept of online study during COVID-19 seems like an interesting and relevant topic, and it’s good to see a paper about this topic. For a time during my studies I have done online study (exclusive and partial) during the pandemic lockdowns.

    For my experience, online study brought lots of pros and cons. I enjoyed studying in the comfort of my own home and it promoted a sense of independence, but I do have to agree that online study brought limitations. While online study was flexible, I do agree it became a disadvantage for those who have not-so-adequate technology or access to technology, and at times could be difficult to interact and readily seek study assistance and/or advice. If you partook in any online study at all during the pandemic, what was your experience like? I’d much really appreciate your opinion and thoughts. Thank you!

  6. Luke Lwin Avatar

    Hi Divyesh,
    Great paper, one of the largest plot holes I found with online education is that when there is a physical interaction needed, it can’t be taught and learnt to its fullest, mostly being medical practice. Do you think that there are benefits that overweigh the negatives that online education has on medical students apart from Telemedicine?
    Thank you, Luke

  7. Sarah.Bailey Avatar
    Sarah.Bailey

    Hi Divyesh,

    This is a very interesting topic (and a relevant one for many of us in this conference, I’m sure!)

    I’m interested on your thoughts on why countless students still choose to study online (either partly or fully), given that you assert that online schooling brought about by COVID-19 instigated ” depression, anxiety and stress”, and “sleep and food disorders, worry over academic grades, and a sense of loneliness”. Many university students, both online and on-campus, report being sleep deprived, worried over their grades, and experiencing difficulty making friends. Do you contest that these facets of tertiary education are especially exacerbated online? I’d be interested in hearing your thoughts on what about online studying makes people more concerned over their grades, for example, than those who study offline.

    I’ve also seen online (and heard from some of my friends), that some people miss online study, because of its flexibility–which in turn reduced their stress. They no longer had to worry about rushing to a 9am tutorial since they could attend from the comfort of their home. They didn’t need to sit and watch an hour-long lecture without a break, pay for on-campus parking, or spend time commuting. I’d also argue that the distance provided by online study through the pandemic reduced stress in some areas (although it may have increased it in others). For one, I was much more comfortable in my ability to social distance when engaging in a tutorial via Collaborate, than I was when sitting in a room with thirty other students. Health-wise, online study provided me with a sense of security and comfort at a time when everyone was still coming to grips with what COVID was and what risks it posed. I’d love to hear your thoughts on this, and how it contrasts with the findings outlined in your paper.

    Looking forward to hearing from you!
    Sarah

    1. Divyesh.Ramloll Avatar
      Divyesh.Ramloll

      Hello Sarah,
      Thanks for the comments.
      We all know how online classes can be easy and flexible. It is good that you felt comfort while doing online classes however many of us did not feel that way. As, it is easy to skip class, loneliness plays a role as well because you are only restricted within your home and there is a possibility of a power cut, or by chance your laptop crash, then there will be nowhere to search for help.
      But, it is good to hear that you did not face those problems.

      1. Sarah.Bailey Avatar
        Sarah.Bailey

        Hi Divyesh,

        Thanks for your response.

        I am interested in why you think people still actively choose online study after it is no longer mandatory, given the exclusively negative implications you outline in your paper. Many people who could conceivably go to campus choose not to, even though you assert online schooling brings about mental health issues and loneliness. To put it another way, if, as you discuss in your paper, online school imparts anxiety, depression, disorders, worry, and stress upon those who undertake it, why would anyone willingly choose to study online? Would you contend that online schooling should not be offered, given the list of detrimental impacts you assert it triggers in your paper?

        Looking forward to hearing your thoughts.
        Sarah

  8. Grace.Kim1 Avatar
    Grace.Kim1

    Hi Divyesh,

    Your paper was such an interesting read, as online education is something that would have affected us all.
    As the only way that nurses could check up on us during COVID pandemic was through call, do you think there should be further implementations for if a future pandemic was to occur?
    In regards to online study, whilst it was flexible, the flexibility made many students slack and not attend class, and it has also made learning difficult if there was any issues with wifi connections or device issues. What are your thoughts on if there was another pandemic to occur?

    I can’t wait to hear your response!

    Regards,
    Grace

  9. Khavish.Mohabeer Avatar
    Khavish.Mohabeer

    Hi Divyesh, I agree with you on the fact that online education was very frustrating and stressful during the covid-19 pandemic and confinement period.

    I have also noticed that while studying online students are also more prone to distractions as for example, a simple notification and they zone out and starts engaging with other things. However, despite having all that disadvantages, I still think studying online can be advantageous as it allows you to be more cautious with your time and it allows you to receive education at any location. Therefore, I wanted to ask, do you think that online education is unfavourable as a whole even in normal circumstances or is it only because of the pandemic?

    Hope to hear from you soon,

    Khavish.

  10. Neema.Najafzadeh Avatar
    Neema.Najafzadeh

    Hey Divyesh,

    Amazing article I could not agree anymore, sometimes I do believe that being a fully online student it does come with its negatives.

    Some points I found interesting Id like to talk about are:

    – The outbreak of coronavirus resulted in global lockdown and home quarantine, leading to moderate to high levels of depression, anxiety, and stress among university students in Jordan.

    – Programs such as TeleMHPSS and hotlines have been put in place to prevent further depressive students, and cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) and spirituality/religiosity may lessen emotional tension.

    – Medical students in Libya were at risk due to the pandemic as lectures and patient-based education are both based on lectures.

    Due to recent events with COVID-19 many physical studying students did get affected heavily, my question to you is:

    Do you think that studying online for your entire course could cause some mental health issues? If so why?

    Looking forward to hearing back from you !

    – Neema Najafzadeh

  11. Dane Goulter Avatar
    Dane Goulter

    Hi,

    Addressing the health and mental health aspects with online education is an important issue and good to see you discussed it. COVID-19 as you suggested was also a big factor in the last few years. I think some of the loneliness some felt would have been a factor already, but adding COVID-19 restrictions really seemed to amplify it for a lot of people. A stronger sense of community and belonging could be a real benefit to many taking part in online education. Additionally, online students often need to manage and motivate themselves, and with adding in mental health issues, it could be making that even more difficult for online students.

    Many of us here are online students and am sure many have experienced this personally. Hopefully, with so many aspects of society moving online, more emphasis will be placed on addressing some of the problems.

  12. NhacLinh.Vo Avatar
    NhacLinh.Vo

    Hi Divyesh.

    Interesting paper to read.

    In my opinion, I think online studying is more beneficial than its negative. Students have flexible time to choose when and where they want to study, which helps them improve their time management skills. In terms of international students, studying online could help them save money and time. For example, as an international student, I had to pay tuition fees, visa fees, accommodation, etc, which are very expensive. Therefore, the online study allows those students to stay home without leaving their country but still get the degree.

    However, I believe some subjects relating to medicine, early childhood education, etc., require students to attend class in person to practice.

  13. Ishan.Thanasekaran Avatar
    Ishan.Thanasekaran

    Hi Divyesh,

    I would say it is an interesting paper to read, it was indeed. But I was just happy that someone brought out the negative impacts of online education. But as usual there are always positive and negatives. I’ve read through the comments and I realised that I too don’t mind online education, there are a lot of benefits of it. But in my own opinion I’d prefer a combination of both. As much as I like online education, I’d want a responsibility of actually attending class in person combined with an online access to do it on my own time as well.

    What are your thoughts on combining both in-person and online education for the same subject?

    Regards,
    Ishan

  14. Mitali.Kangalee Avatar
    Mitali.Kangalee

    Hi Divyesh,

    Your essay provided a thorough analysis of how the COVID-19 epidemic has affected education, with a special emphasis on the benefits and drawbacks of using social media for distance education. It’s obvious that the pandemic has caused major disruptions and brought to light a number of problems that children and teachers face.

    I wonder how we can guarantee that all students, even those from low-income backgrounds who may not have access to computers and the internet, have the chance to benefit from online learning opportunities?

    Kind regards,
    Mitali.

Skip to content